With a powerhouse cast and a huge fan base, this has to be a must-see, right?

Well … alas, not every musical translates well from stage to screen.

Unfortunately, “Dear Evan Hansen” seems to fall into the latter category.

Ben Platt at Dear Evan Hansen event

At 27, casting him as a high school senior is a challenge, even with his talent.

Twitter is exploding with jokes and memes (likethis one) poking fun of the actor’s age.

The plot of the film is also making viewers squirm (spoiler alerts ahead).

Dear Evan Hansen poster

The deception deepens as Evan bonds with Connor’s parents and develops a relationship with his sister.

On-stage, this concept somehow works; on film, it reportedly comes off as creepy.

Still, at least one expert is applauding “Dear Evan Hansen” for addressing a vital issue.

Dr. Harold Koplewicz, founder of the Child Mind Institute, wrote an essay on the film forNBC News.

Stories that show there aren’t quick fixes."