There are some romantic comedy films that just seem to be a perfect fit with the cast.

“Serendipity” is one of those films.

The pair hit it off and spend a fateful night strolling around NYC and having deep conversations.

Jennifer Aniston at an event

However, they both reveal that they’re in relationships.

However, Aniston shockingly passed on the role, perBuzzfeed.

The role ultimately went to Kate Beckinsale, who nailed the part.

Kate Beckinsale poses for a photo